The Huffington Post Palestinian Territories
Log In | Sign Up | January 7, 2009
Spread Awareness - Stumble this Big News Page



Links From Digg, Delicious, and Google Blogsearch

Marjorie Cohn: Israel's Collective Punishment of Gaza



Comments
296
Pending Comments
5
Post Comment

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next › Last » (17 pages total)
- New jackwaddington See Profile I'm a Fan of jackwaddington permalink

The propaganda, spin and rhetoric that the US and Israel is putting forth is beginning to be seen for what it is. "Spin". Israel and the Israeli politicians are playing a very dangerous game with themselves, their nation and Judaism. The world is now turning against them and this will make it so uncomfortable for Israel and the Israelis to live, let alone in peace for very much longer, however, they attempt to maintain their military superiority. Incredibly there are quite a few Jews who are now beginning to see this (in varying depth) and this raises the specter of a cultural demise of Judaism. The regional bully, for all it's excuses, is beginning to be seen as just that: The regional bully..

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:39 PM on 01/07/2009
- New LJMom See Profile I'm a Fan of LJMom permalink

I couldn't agree more with Marjorie's article. It's so typical...the U.S. blocks everything when it comes to Israel, and you would think that the Congress and Senate are a part of the Israeli Government rather than the U.S. When are people in this Country going to wake up and realize that what is happening is not in our best interest. You cannot stand back and watch such suffering being inflicted on others without it eventually coming back to haunt you.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:23 PM on 01/07/2009
- elghoul See Profile I'm a Fan of elghoul permalink


For the blind and only the blind. See and hear this documentaty told by some Israeli veterans.
The truth and only the truth of what is going on...
1- http://current.com/items/89660292/many_israeli_soldiers_speak_out_against_israels_inhumanity_against_palestinians.htm

2- http://www.breakingthesilenceexhibit.org/

The ones who do not know will never equal the ones who do know...

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:50 PM on 01/07/2009
- NetProphet See Profile I'm a Fan of NetProphet permalink

On the whole - a very good article. Israel using poisonous phosphorous gas. This is nothing new, though, all of us who keep up with the Palestinian-Israel peace fiasco are well aware of its shannigans. Never hear this on the MSM. Try the BBC; they, at least, give much more info the US media leaves out!!!

Keep in mind, however, the REASON WHY Hamas has been shooting rockets into the deserts of Israel: Cut-off roads, ports, public utilities still stiffeled for the Gazans, etc., etc.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:50 PM on 01/07/2009
- mheister See Profile I'm a Fan of mheister permalink

Where was the indignation of Ms. Cohn and her fellows at the National Lawyers' Guild when Hamas illegally conducted a civil war and expelled elected Hamas leaders from Gaza??? Or while Hamas was firing rockets indiscriminately into Israel??? Or when Hamas leaders repeated ad nauseum their cant that all Jews must be resettled elsewhere by the Americans and Europeans who, according to Hamas, put them there??? (slightly more humane than pushing them into the sea, but still....)

Where, for that matter, is Cohn's or the NLG's indignation at Hamas for violating the rules of engagement by placing military targets in or in the proximity of schools, hospitals, and places of worship???

Other commenters here have pointed out the obvious - Israel withdrew from Gaza. Completely. Even after expelling Fatah, Hamas had an historic opportunity to declare independence, appeal for international aid, and start exchanging ambassadors. They chose instead to continue this war of attrition against Israel.

The entire situation is tragic. The suffering is unspeakable. However, Ms. Cohn, there is plenty of responsibility for this to be shared. To lay all the blame on Israel is to assume the infantilization of the Palestinians as a result of their oppression by the Jewish state and their extended use as political pawns by a range of Arab and/or Islamic states. Hamas is many things, but one thing they are not is children simply behaving reflexively in response to their Israeli parents.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:39 PM on 01/07/2009
- New chaos4700 See Profile I'm a Fan of chaos4700 permalink

False dichotomy. People can -- and do -- criticize Hamas terrorism just as readily as they do Israel's war crimes.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:12 PM on 01/07/2009
Page: 1 2 3 4 5